Thousands are Serving Life Without Parole Sentences in Pennsylvania. A Board of Pardons Hearing Might Begin to Change That.
Joshua Vaughn - September 11, 2019
People seeking commutations from life sentences encounter a steep hurdle in the state’s board of pardons. The board will convene on Sept. 13 to review more than 20 cases.
On Feb. 13, 1991, Terri-Joell Harper planned to celebrate Valentine’s Day with her boyfriend Donnell Drinks by going out for a night on the town in Philadelphia.
Harper was excited to spend the evening with Drinks and looking forward to the future: She had completed the police academy and recently joined the Philadelphia Police Department.
Before the night began, Drinks—who had showered Harper with gifts and convinced her that he was a successful, older businessman—said he had to collect a debt. The two then drove to the Philadelphia home of Darryl Huntley and waited for more than two hours for him to arrive.
Around 11 p.m., Huntley and his girlfriend returned home. Harper, then 22, and Drinks, then 17, forced them inside at gunpoint with intent to rob them. Drinks handcuffed Huntley and took him upstairs while Harper filled bags with items from the home.
But when Huntley slipped out of his handcuffs, he grabbed Drinks’s gun and shot him. Drinks then pulled a knife and stabbed Huntley, who later died from his injuries.
At the time, Harper’s attorney described her as an unwitting accomplice to murder taken on a “rollercoaster ride from hell” by Drinks.
In December 1992, Harper pleaded guilty to second-degree murder under the felony-murder doctrine which punishes people for murder when a death occurs during the commission of a felony. A Philadelphia judge sentenced her to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
In 1993, Drinks was convicted of first-degree murder and also sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. But in April 2018, he was resentenced and later released on parole. In 2012, the U.S. Supreme Court deemed mandatory life sentences for children to be unconstitutional, and in 2016 the court made that ruling retroactive.
Because Harper was an adult at the time of the offense, she is not eligible for resentencing. After serving more than 25 years in prison, her only hope for freedom is a commutation from Pennsylvania Governor Tom Wolf.
But before Harper’s case goes before the governor, she must receive approval from all five members of the state Board of Pardons, which is composed of the lieutenant governor, the attorney general, a victims’ advocate, a corrections expert, and a psychiatrist. In 2017 and 2018, seven of nine people who requested commutations had their request denied.
On Friday, Harper’s case will be among 21 heard by the board. The hearings will nearly double the number of commutations from life sentences considered by the board since Governor Wolf took office in 2015.
In 1974, there were fewer than 500 people serving life without parole in Pennsylvania. There are now more than 5,400 people doing life in Pennsylvania, one of the highest rates of life without parole sentences in the country. Most of Pennsylvania’s lifers will die behind bars if the Board of Pardons does not recommend a commutation to the governor. And a single vote against commutation is sufficient to prevent a recommendation to the governor.
In December 2017, Attorney General Josh Shapiro cast the lone dissenting vote against a commutation for William “Smitty” Smith, then 76. He had been incarcerated for nearly 50 years for serving as an accomplice in a 1968 robbery that left one man dead and another permanently injured. In 1992, the board recommended Smith for a commutation, which Governor Bob Casey never approved. In 2017, advocates blasted Shapiro’s vote, and in May 2018 he reversed course and approved Smith’s commutation.
“We have inmates in our system who have done 40 years and never taken a life directly,” Lt. Gov. John Fetterman, who chairs the Board of Pardons, told The Philadelphia Inquirer. “I think it’s critical that we examine that and, when it merits it, make sure we give them another chance to rebuild their lives and contribute to society.”
Fetterman, who took office in January and ran on a criminal justice reform platform, said he supports a soon to be introduced state constitutional amendment that would allow commutation recommendations with a vote of at least four to one.
To read more, click here.